Irish Coffee Pub

Located in the heart of East Islip, NY, Irish Coffee Pub proudly serves as a quintessential Irish restaurant and bar that masterfully combines traditional Irish fare with a warm, inviting atmosphere. This beloved local gem offers a truly authentic taste of Ireland, making it an essential destination for those craving hearty, comforting meals paired with expertly crafted drinks. Whether you're settling in for a casual night out or celebrating a special occasion, Irish Coffee Pub delivers a dining experience that feels both timeless and genuinely heartfelt.

The menu is a celebration of classic Irish and American favorites with a refined twist. Start your evening indulging in starters like the perfectly seasoned Fried Calamari accompanied by a spicy homemade pomodoro sauce or the Grilled Prosciutto Wrapped Fresh Mozzarella served with marinated tomatoes and garlic bread—each bite bursting with flavor and thoughtful preparation. For soup lovers, the Cream of Spud and the French Onion Au Gratinée offer rich, savory warmth that feels like a comforting embrace.

Signature dishes such as the iconic Shepherd's Pie and the perfectly tender Corned Beef and Cabbage Potatoes showcase authentic Irish comfort food at its best, made with care and tradition. Meat lovers will revel in the Filet Mignon paired with creamy mashed potatoes, while seafood enthusiasts will delight in the fresh, flaky Sea Bass or the classic Jumbo White Shrimp Cocktail served with tangy cocktail sauce and fresh lemon. The Pub Salad provides a refreshing contrast, perfectly balancing the richness of the heartier plates.

Highlighting the drink menu is a selection of fine Irish beers like Guinness and expertly mixed cocktails such as the whimsical Mother's Milk and the crisp, refreshing Whiskey Sour. These complement the food exquisitely, rounding out an evening that indulges all the senses.

What truly sets Irish Coffee Pub apart, however, is its atmosphere—a cozy yet vibrant space where warmth extends beyond the hearth. The staff’s genuine hospitality leaves guests feeling like cherished friends. This is a place where memories are made and celebrated time and again; just ask the countless couples who have chosen Irish Coffee Pub for their weddings and anniversaries. Sharon M’s heartfelt reminiscence of celebrating 25 years of marriage here perfectly encapsulates the special, enduring connection guests feel. Stephen, the manager, along with the entire team, is repeatedly praised for their thoughtful attention and creating an environment where every visit feels like coming home.

From intimate dinners to joyous gatherings, Irish Coffee Pub offers more than great food and drink—it offers an experience steeped in community, tradition, and genuine care. For anyone looking to savor authentic Irish flavors served with warmth and pride, this is the place to be.